On the eve of Nancy Guthrie going missing, her son-in-law, Tommaso Cioni, dropped her off at her home around 9:48 p.m. after dinner at her daughter Annie Guthrie’s home.
Two minutes later, according to the Pima County Sheriff’s Department, she entered her Catalina Foothills home after the garage door opened and closed.
But with the age of 84 and facing mobility issues, questions were raised about how she could get inside the house in such a brief duration.
Revisiting the matter, the former FBI special agent, Maureen O’Connell, who visited the site, cast doubt on the ‘two-minute’ timeline shared by the Pima County Sheriff’s Department.
She told host Brian Entin on his show, “This place in front of Nancy’s house was so peaceful. It was crazy.”
Darkness, O’Connell pointed out, led her to question the duration mentioned in the official report.
“And then at nighttime, it’s pitch black. They don’t even allow front porch lights, or you can’t have a light over your garage.”
Due to this, the ex-FBI agent shared his doubt, “Which really called into question that whole 2-minute timeline with the garage door being open.”
“I’ve thought about that again, and I’ve revisited it, and I’ve come to some different kind of conclusions on that,” she added.
O’Connell then said the only possibility that could make the ‘2-minute’ timeline is that “I’m thinking the only way that 2-minute timeline could make any sense at all is if Tommaso pulled up, backed up to the garage door, walked around, got Nancy out of the car, stood in front of the garage door, and then opened it on his app, walked in, and closed it right away.”
She continued, “I find that hard to believe because without exterior lights, unless they had a big motion detector light up there, which I did not see, what are they doing?”
“What, does he have a huge flashlight in his hand? It just made me think that was even less probable.”
After sharing her view, O’Connell concluded, “All I know is that number — there’s a reason everybody’s scratching their head. And that number is one of them.”
Guthrie, meanwhile, remains disappeared since Feb. 1, when she was reported missing, as an investigation into her case is ongoing.
