LatestPakistanTop News

Tarar responds to Bilawal’s criticism of system, says debate on new provinces cannot be stopped

Says political parties have been part of existing system for decades, cannot distance themselves from its shortcomings

Information Minister Attaullah Tarar responds to a statement by Pakistan Peoples Party Chairman Bilawal Bhutto Zardari on Tuesday. Screengrab APP/X

Information Minister Attaullah Tarar on Tuesday said the debate over good governance and creating new provinces could not be stopped, stressing that good governance was the democratic right of the people.

The remarks come after Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) Chairman Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari called for a “political reset” to restore confidence in the country’s institutions, saying the political system had not collapsed on its own but had been deliberately dismantled.

Responding to Bilawal’s statement earlier in the day, Tarar underlined that people wanted good governance, improved public services and a government accountable to them.

Read: Bilawal calls for ‘political reset’, says system ‘deliberately destroyed’

“Today we heard Bilawal’s talk in Karachi, and I want to present a few points. There is a debate on good governance in the country right now, and this is a subject close to the public, which wants an accountable government.”

Referring to the debate over the creation of new provinces, Tarar emphasised the discussion could not be halted, adding that it was a “democratic and constitutional requirement” for the debate to continue.

The minister added: “The real problem is the ongoing debate over new provinces, and this is the reason behind today’s comments. This debate is vigorously taking place in the public domain. Should people be stopped from talking about new provinces and the need for good governance? This debate will continue inside parliament and outside it, and it is a democratic necessity that this debate be allowed to continue.” 

Tarar further argued that no political party should have reservations about going to the public on the issue of new provinces, adding that “a referendum is a part of the constitution, not a backdoor. The people are the final decision makers, and we need to respect the will of the people. Good governance and reforms are part of the agenda of all governments”.

The minister further remarked that if the people of Pakistan wanted more provinces, they should be created, adding that talk of “shedding blood” over the issue was beyond comprehension.

Read More: New provinces not anyone’s wish but Pakistan’s need: Mustafa Kamal

He added: “The people of the whole of Pakistan, including Sindh, will decide whether they want new provinces or not. The people’s representatives come from the people, not the other way around.”

Tarar said that the creation of smaller administrative units should be seen in a “constructive manner” and not be made a subject of controversy. “If referendums were misused in the past, should the people remain deprived of their right to good governance and their democratic rights? This is no justification. We are part of one government, and we should come and work together on this issue.”

Tarar noted that all political parties had been part of the existing system for decades and could not distance themselves from its weaknesses. “We have been part of this system for decades, and now we cannot divorce ourselves from the weakness of this system.” 

“Using politics as a pretext to seek exemption from accountability is unacceptable to both the public and the law,” the minister said, adding that there was no room for such an approach.

Taking a swipe at the PPP, Tarar stated: “It is a contradiction in principle to benefit from government privileges and then to act as the opposition, to secure protocol and ministries and also to take the high moral ground; these are all double standards.”

He also questioned the criticism of the National Accountability Bureau (NAB), saying that reforms to the accountability body had themselves been introduced by those now holding it responsible for the system’s shortcomings.

Background of debate over new provinces

The current debate over new provinces began on July 30, when Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi called for additional administrative units or provinces as part of a broader overhaul of the country’s governance system. Naqvi argued that meaningful structural reforms were needed to improve governance, deliver justice and create opportunities for young people.

The proposal quickly became politically sensitive in Sindh, where the PPP strongly opposed any move to divide the province. Sindh Chief Minister Murad Ali Shah rejected Naqvi’s assessment that the governance system had collapsed and called the proposal outdated, warning that no bloodshed would be allowed over the creation of new provinces.

The debate widened in August when Muttahida Qaumi Movement–Pakistan (MQM-P) backed the creation of new provinces and called for a national dialogue with political parties. The party argued that Pakistan’s growing population, poor governance and concentration of political power made greater administrative devolution necessary. The move put the party, which is part of the federal coalition but sits in opposition in Sindh, at odds with the PPP’s position on the province.

Also Read: Presidency denies discussion on new units with Naqvi

The PPP, meanwhile, maintained that administrative reform and the division of Sindh were separate questions. Sindh minister Nasir Hussain Shah said the provincial government was willing to discuss measures to improve governance and devolve power, but rejected linking those reforms to the creation of a new province.

The dispute reached the Sindh Assembly at the beginning of September. On September 3, the house unanimously passed a resolution rejecting any proposal to divide Sindh or alter its territorial limits. The resolution described Sindh as a “historic, civilisational and constitutional entity” and declared that “Sindh is one and shall remain one”.

Naqvi, however, showed no sign of backing away. On September 5, he said he would continue to support new provinces regardless of whether he remained in office, arguing that the ultimate decision should belong to the people rather than politicians or governments. He said the public should first be told the “pros and cons” of creating new administrative units before being allowed to decide.

Also Read: Naqvi vows not to back down from demand for new provinces, says decision must reflect public will

That position has since raised another question over how public opinion could be formally established. A constitutional debate emerged over whether a referendum could be used to gauge support for new provinces. Article 48(6) allows a matter of national importance to be put to a referendum following approval by a joint sitting of Parliament, although a referendum itself would not create a new province; any change to provincial boundaries would still have to follow the constitutional process.

Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf’s (PTI’s) Barrister Gohar Ali Khan warned on September 7 that dividing Sindh or any other province without the consent of its people and representatives would weaken the federation. He called for a commission and extensive deliberations before the issue was taken to parliament.

Defence Minister Khawaja Asif, while accepting that Sindh had the right to take its own position, also said a final decision would have to emerge through consensus. Asif separately suggested that Islamabad could be used as a starting point for any future administrative restructuring, while Prime Minister’s Adviser Rana Sanaullah said the question of new provinces should be taken up at the relevant forums and resolved through consensus among political parties.



Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button